| | | |

25 Air Fryer Side Dishes That Keep the Oven Free on Christmas Day

Air Fryer Parmesan Potatoes

By nine on Christmas morning Nonna’s oven is full, and it stays full until the teglia of lasagna comes out to rest. Nobody opens that door without asking her, and I have asked.

So last year I brought my secondhand air fryer over from the apartment, ran an extension cord down to the old basement counter and set it up next to the tomato jars. Mrs. Carbone came downstairs twice to check on the potatoes, which meant she wanted one early.

That is the arrangement now. The oven is spoken for on Christmas Day, so the sides moved downstairs one basket at a time. Nonna called the air fryer a toy when I plugged it in. By two she was sending people down with empty plates.

WANT TO SAVE THIS ARTICLE?

Enter your email below & we'll send it straight to your inbox.

These are the twenty-five that get served at her table, and each one has its recipe here on the site. I will tell you which ones hold for an hour and which have to go out the minute the basket opens.

#1 Air Fryer Parmesan Potatoes

Air Fryer Parmesan Potatoes

Small red potatoes cut in half, skin on, the cut side pressed into grated parmesan until it browns into a lacy crust that sticks. A little parsley, black pepper and garlic over the top. That is the whole plate, and it goes empty first.

My roommate calls them parmesan potatoes, Mrs. Carbone calls them cheese potatoes, and Nonna calls them cheating, because real roast potatoes come out of an oven. She still eats four. Nobody has won.

They go in around noon in Nonna’s basement, single layer, so two batches for a full table. Fifteen minutes cut side down, then I turn them, add more cheese and give them five to ten more, exactly as the parmesan potato recipe on the site says.

The crust goes soft after half an hour on the table, so batch two goes in while the lasagna rests and arrives hot.

#2 Air Fryer Smashed Potatoes

Air Fryer Smashed Potatoes

The flat thud of a glass coming down on a potato is the sound of mid-afternoon in Nonna’s basement on the 25th. Nonna calls down to ask if I’m angry at somebody. Usually I’m not.

At the parish potluck every January, somebody’s smashed potatoes sat under foil for an hour and went soft as bread. Nobody complained, which in that hall was its own kind of review.

This version skips the boiling pot, which matters when the burners are spoken for. Baby potatoes, olive oil, garlic and thyme at 370 degrees, done inside half an hour. I follow the smashed potato recipe on the site and run two batches, because one basket never covers the table.

They go in while the lasagna rests and come out straight to the plates. Left on a platter, they lose the crunch fast, so I yell up the stairs before opening the basket.

Easy Swap: If the store is out of baby potatoes on the 24th, small reds, fingerlings or new potatoes work fine. Halve anything bigger and set it cut side down in the basket so the flat face gets the crust.

#3 Air Fryer Potato Wedges

Air Fryer Potato Wedges

Eleven-thirty on Christmas morning, and the big stockpot in Nonna’s basement is full of cold water and cut potatoes. That pot is the reason the wedges work.

The first time I made them, in my apartment, I cut the russets, oiled them and threw them straight in, all at once. My roommate lifted one out with two fingers and said, “This one’s sweating.” Pale, soft, stuck together. The soak pulls out the starch, and a single layer lets them crisp.

Now they sit in the water at least an hour, get rinsed, dried on a dish towel and tossed with olive oil, salt, pepper and oregano. The wedges recipe on the site runs them at 380°F, and I shake the basket.

They go in two batches while Nonna’s lasagna rests, and they go out the minute they’re done. Wedges don’t hold.

#4 Air Fryer Baby Potatoes

Air Fryer Baby Potatoes

By two o’clock on Christmas Nonna’s table is already crowded: the lasagna on its trivet, the roast waiting for her knife. There is always one open spot near the bread, and that is where the little potatoes go.

I learned these the first year Nonna handed me the basement air fryer. I stood at the counter patting every potato dry like I was defusing something, then called up the stairs, “How much garlic powder is too much?” She called back that there is no such thing. I used the whole tablespoon.

They go in while the lasagna rests, skins on, tossed in olive oil, oregano, salt and pepper. The version I landed on is the baby potato recipe on the site, word for word.

They hold better than most, warm or room temperature. Parsley goes on at the counter. I make these all winter in my apartment.

#5 Air Fryer Diced Potatoes

Air Fryer Diced Potatoes

The air fryer basket holds one modest pan’s worth of potatoes, which in my house is nothing, so these go in twice, back to back.

Nonna Pina had a rule: once a potato is cut, it never goes back under the faucet. “You’re washing the good part down the drain,” she’d say, and move my hand off the tap. This is the one place I break it. The half-inch cubes go into cold water, then get patted dry, because rinsing off the starch is what crisps the edges.

After that it’s olive oil, garlic powder, sweet paprika, salt, pepper and parsley, straight from the diced potato recipe on the site.

First batch goes in while the lasagna rests. Small cubes don’t hold on a crowded table; give them ten minutes and they go soft, so they get passed hot or not at all.

#6 Air Fryer Sliced Potatoes

Air Fryer Sliced Potatoes

By two o’clock on the 25th the basement window over the counter is fogged solid, and whoever walks past writes their initials in it. Outside it is gray and spitting sleet. Inside, the air fryer has been going since noon.

These slices started as a Lent thing. One Friday in March my roommate looked at a plate of baked cod and said, “Fish again. Is there at least a potato?” I sliced three Yukon Golds thin, tossed them with olive oil, garlic, salt, pepper and Italian spices, and she stopped asking. Nonna heard about it and put them on the Christmas list.

On Christmas they go in once the antipasto is cleared, two batches, and they go out the minute they’re done. Thin slices go limp on a crowded table inside twenty minutes. The sliced potato recipe on the site is the one I make every Friday until Easter, too.

Easy Swap: For a holiday version, the recipe’s own variation adds parmesan and a little rosemary in the last two or three minutes. Toss the slices well so the cheese melts onto the potatoes instead of the basket.

#7 Air Fryer Potato Puffs

Air Fryer Potato Puffs

The first bite cracks, then gives way to soft potato, and if you wait five minutes it doesn’t crack at all. That is the whole lesson with these, and it took me one Christmas of soggy puffs to learn it.

I ate my first real potato croquettes standing on a street in Naples, out of a paper cone, burning my fingers because the man behind the counter said, “Adesso, signora.” Now, not later. He was right then, and he is right in my basement.

Angie’s potato puffs recipe on the site is russets mashed with cornstarch, parsley, salt and pepper, rolled into balls with oiled hands. I shape them in the morning, then crisp them in the air fryer between the pasta and the roast. They go to the table in the basket, and the basket does not come back full.

#8 Air Fryer Garlic Parmesan Fries

Air Fryer Garlic Parmesan Fries

Potatoes, olive oil, garlic, parmesan, salt and pepper. Five things on one hand, plus a pinch of oregano, so I never look anything up on Christmas Day.

The idea came from next door. Two Christmases ago Mrs. Carbone’s grandson brought over a paper plate of fries and said, “Nonna says your kids won’t eat eggplant.” He was right.

The potatoes soak in cold water from noon, at least half an hour, then get patted dry. They go in the basket once the antipasto is cleared, with some parmesan in the last few minutes and more over the top.

These do not hold. Ten minutes on a crowded table and they go soft, so I run them up the basement stairs the minute they’re done. The garlic parmesan fries recipe on the site is the one I use.

#9 Air Fryer Sweet Potato Wedges

Air Fryer Sweet Potato Wedges

I stand at the basement counter on Christmas Day with a dish towel over my shoulder, and nobody touches the air fryer basket while the sweet potato wedges are in it. I claimed the job three years ago. Nonna let me keep it; she doesn’t trust the buttons.

These showed up the year I moved off the card table and onto the real one. Mrs. DiNapoli got the seat next to me. She refuses anything orange, and she ate half the platter because of the Parmesan and rosemary.

They go in between the pasta and the roast, and they go out the minute they’re done, because sweet potato turns soft sitting on a table already packed with platters. I follow the sweet potato wedges recipe on the site, paprika and oregano and all, and I double it. The first basketful never makes it up the stairs.

#10 Air Fryer Brussels Sprouts

Air Fryer Brussels Sprouts

Leaves browned at the edges until they crackle, a few loose ones gone to chips, parmesan melted into every fold, black pepper. That is what comes to the table, in a smaller pile than you’d think.

At the end of the night Nonna walks the counter with the stack of deli containers, deciding who takes what home. Nobody has ever packed these. Last Christmas Mrs. Carbone stood over the empty basket picking out the burnt leaves with her fingers before I could rinse it, and swore me to secrecy.

They go in between the pasta and the roast and come out when the plates go down, because they do not hold; ten minutes next to the gravy boat and the crunch is gone. I keep the basket loose, never piled. Olive oil, parmesan, salt, pepper; the crispy Brussels sprouts recipe on the site is the one I follow.

Cook's Tip: Buy sprouts that are firm, compact and bright green with the leaves closed tight. Yellow ones or ones with loose, damaged leaves have been sitting too long, and on Christmas you have no time to trim around them.

#11 Smashed Brussels Sprouts

Smashed Brussels Sprouts

Thump, thump, thump. That is a juice glass coming down on the cutting board, and it is how the whole basement knows the sprouts are on.

The first year, they went upstairs on Nonna’s white oval platter with the gold rim. The last few went home with Mrs. Carbone under foil, platter and all. Nonna has stopped asking.

I boil and ice-bath them in the morning, dry them, and leave them on the cold counter. Once the antipasto is cleared, they get smashed, brushed with the garlic, olive oil and parmesan, and brushed again at the flip.

They do not hold. Crisp edges go soft the minute they sit between the gravy bowl and the bread basket, so they go up a few at a time and get eaten standing. The smashed sprouts recipe on the site is the one I follow.

#12 Air Fryer Baby Carrots

Air Fryer Baby Carrots

Quarter to two on the 25th, the roast is resting under foil, and Mrs. Carbone wants to know if there’s anything orange on the table. Baby carrots, a spoon of oil, garlic, Parmesan, and they go into the basement air fryer at 400.

Nonna does carrots one way: boiled in the dented saucepan with the loose handle, the one she refuses to replace because it “knows carrots.” They come out soft enough to cut with a fork, and nobody fights over them.

These get fought over. Single layer, shake the basket halfway, twelve to fifteen minutes, and the Parmesan crisps at the edges. The carrot recipe on the site works with frozen too, which is how my roommate and I eat them all winter.

Christmas rule: they go from the basket straight to the plates, and nobody waits on them. Cold, they lose the crunch and sit there.

#13 Air Fryer Carrot Fries

Air Fryer Carrot Fries

By three o’clock the table is all red and brown: gravy, meatballs, the lasagna, a roast. Something orange has to land on it, and these carrot fries are it.

I started making them the Christmas the roads iced over and Mrs. Carbone couldn’t get across the bridge with her green beans. Nonna stood at the basement fridge holding a bag of carrots and said, “This is the only vegetable in the house. Do something.” Three large carrots, olive oil, garlic powder, salt and pepper.

Now they go in between the pasta and the roast, while everybody loosens a belt. About fifteen minutes and they’re done. They won’t wait for anybody. Ten minutes on the table and they go soft, so I carry them up the stairs hot and they get eaten standing.

The carrot fries recipe on the site is the one I follow, all winter long.

#14 Air Fryer Butternut Squash

Air Fryer Butternut Squash

The squash goes into the green melamine bowl with the chipped rim, the one I carried home from a parish rummage sale for a dollar. Oil, salt, a pinch of black pepper, cinnamon, one turn of the spoon.

I wouldn’t touch it until I was nineteen. I called it orange baby food, to Mrs. DiNapoli’s face. Then one Christmas I ate it standing at her basement counter and asked who changed the recipe. Nobody, she said. You did.

It goes in at 375 once the antipasto is cleared, spread in one layer so the pieces crisp instead of going soft. It holds on the table better than the potatoes, tender inside and crisp at the edges. The butternut squash recipe on the site is the one I follow, and I cut the cubes a little bigger than it says, because Mrs. DiNapoli picks out the big ones first.

Make Ahead: Peel, seed and cut the squash on Christmas Eve and keep it covered in the fridge. Toss it with the oil and spices only when the basket is hot, or the salt pulls out water and it won’t crisp.

#15 Air Fryer Cauliflower

Air Fryer Cauliflower

By three o’clock on Christmas the basement window over the counter is fogged solid, rain pretending to be snow on Mrs. DiNapoli’s car. The air fryer adds its own cloud every time the basket comes out.

My friend Gina works the late shift at the hospital most Christmases. She knocks on the back door around eleven, coat still on, and the plate I saved her always has the cauliflower, cold, feta gone soft into the browned edges. She eats it standing at the fridge and swears it’s better that way.

So this is the side I don’t rush. The air fryer cauliflower on the site is florets tossed with olive oil, garlic powder, sweet paprika, salt and pepper, one layer, 375°F, twelve to fifteen minutes with a shake halfway. It goes in once the antipasto is cleared, and the feta goes on hot so it sinks into the edges.

#16 Air Fryer Whole Cauliflower

Air Fryer Whole Cauliflower

The first forkful goes through to the core with no fight, and the outside has gone the color of a terra-cotta pot from the paprika. Priya took one bite, eyed the air fryer, and asked why we never did this before.

Because it was never on the list. The list for the 25th runs two pages, and cauliflower only showed up the year I found a head hiding in the crisper behind the escarole.

Now it goes in on purpose, downstairs. I boil it ten minutes once the antipasto is cleared, dry it with a dish towel, brush on the olive oil, garlic powder and paprika, and give it 20 minutes at 370°F. Angie’s whole cauliflower recipe needs no flipping, which matters on the 25th.

It holds a half hour on the table, parsley on at the end, and I cut it in wedges like a cake.

#17 Air Fryer Frozen Broccoli

Air Fryer Frozen Broccoli

Frozen florets, olive oil, salt, black pepper. Four fingers, and the thumb is for a little parmesan if you want it. It is the shortest card in my Christmas pile.

It also started the longest argument. My friend Jess swears you thaw it first. “You put ice in that machine, you get mush,” she said last year, standing guard over the basket. The recipe says straight from the bag, tossed in oil, one layer at 400 degrees. The edges came out brown and crisp, and she moved the bowl to her end of the table.

It goes in between the pasta and the roast, about ten minutes, and nobody waits for it: basket to bowl to table. Left sitting, it goes soft, and Jess counts that as a win. Shake the basket once, halfway. The frozen broccoli recipe on the site has the times.

#18 Air Fryer Zucchini

Air Fryer Zucchini

I’m the one standing at Nonna’s basement counter at four o’clock, because she put me in charge of the zucchini and I take it more seriously than the roast. Rounds, not too thin. One tablespoon of olive oil, salt, pepper, chopped parsley, and the parmesan if she isn’t looking.

I got that from the Lenten potluck at St. Rita’s, where Mrs. Carbone brought a foil tray of zucchini every year and it sat until it went limp. “Zucchini waits for nobody,” Nonna said, and took a piece from the corner anyway.

So it goes in between the pasta and the roast, and it travels straight from the basket to the plates. Soft and golden turns soggy in ten minutes next to the gravy boat. I follow the air fryer zucchini recipe on the site, and I still shake the basket halfway, like a pan of chestnuts.

Common Mistake: Piling the rounds two deep in the basket. They steam instead of browning and come out pale and wet. Keep them in one layer and run another batch rather than squeeze them in.

#19 Portobello Mushroom Fries

Portobello Mushroom Fries

Thick strips of portobello, each one in a jacket of crumbs gone deep gold, stacked on my chipped platter with a dish of gravy beside them.

The first time, in my apartment, I rinsed the caps under the tap like lettuce and never scraped out the gills. The batter soaked through, the basket went dark and soft, and Priya held one up and asked why it was gray.

Now I wipe each cap with a clean cloth, spoon out the gills, and dip the strips in flour-and-water batter before the crumbs. Panko if I have it. The seasoning is in the portobello fries recipe on the site: garlic powder, Italian seasoning, salt, pepper.

They go in around four when friends are over, between the pasta and the roast, and go straight from basket to plates. Nobody waits. Ten minutes on the table and the crust gives up.

#20 Air Fryer Onions

Air Fryer Onions

The knife hits the board in a tap-tap-tap, then stops, and somebody sniffs. That is my friend Teresa at my kitchen counter, slicing onions with her eyes half shut, the way the men did at every parish funeral lunch.

I learned the trick standing on a chair when I was nine: run the blade under cold water before you start, and again whenever it dries. Teresa didn’t believe me two Christmases ago. She wet the knife anyway, got through four onions without a tissue, and now considers it her own discovery.

The air fryer onions on the site are olive oil, salt and pepper, piled into the basket without worrying about overlap, and stirred now and then for ten to twelve minutes. They go in while the roast rests and hold fine, spooned over the meat or onto bread. Leftovers keep four days; the last spoonful goes into Monday’s eggs.

#21 Air Fryer Onion Rings

Air Fryer Onion Rings

Twenty to five on Christmas afternoon. The roast is resting under foil, and Frankie from next door is leaning on my counter asking where the onion rings are.

There is an old rule about holiday frying: nothing crisp leaves the kitchen before the table is set, because whoever eats standing up never sits down. I break it every year with these, and nobody has complained yet.

The onion ring recipe on the site is a batter of flour, paprika and cold sparkling water, then breadcrumbs and a little oil. They crunch without a pot of oil on two burners that are already full.

They are good for about five minutes on a platter, then the crust goes soft. I make them last, when the carving starts, one layer at a time so the rings never stack. The first round never reaches the table. Frankie sees to that.

#22 Air Fryer Roasted Tomatoes

Air Fryer Roasted Tomatoes

By the time Mrs. DiNapoli sits down on Christmas, the table has the lasagna, the roast sliced thicker than anyone asked for, the eggplant, and one empty space near the bread. That space is for blistered cherry tomatoes.

I started making them on a Friday in Lent, when meat was off the table and a coworker over for dinner said a plate of pasta looked lonely. A pint of cherry tomatoes, olive oil, salt, oregano, pepper, a splash of balsamic. She ate half at my counter on bread before I sat down.

On Christmas they go into my secondhand air fryer once the antipasto is cleared, because the roasted tomato recipe on the site is done in under fifteen minutes. Pull them when the first skins split. Basil goes on as I carry them to the table, and Mrs. DiNapoli mops up the juice with the heel of the bread.

Cook's Tip: Keep the tomatoes in a single layer in the basket. Piled two deep, they steam instead of blistering, and you lose the charred edges that make them worth the trouble.

#23 Air Fryer Roasted Garlic

Air Fryer Roasted Garlic

The smallest thing that goes in the basket all day is a head of garlic with its top sliced off, a spoon of olive oil poured over the cut, salt, pepper, and a sprig of thyme from the pot on my windowsill.

In Rome, on my one trip, a waiter set a whole roasted head next to the bread and walked away without a word. My friend Gina looked at me like it was a test. I squeezed a clove onto her crust, and she didn’t talk for five minutes.

On the 25th it goes in first, at noon, 375°F for about twenty minutes, before the potatoes need the room. It holds on a saucer by the bread, soft enough to spread with a butter knife.

Any clove that survives gets mashed into butter for the leftover bread; the timing is in the roasted garlic recipe on the site.

#24 Air Fryer Garlic Toast

Air Fryer Garlic Toast

When I host friends around Christmas, somebody starts asking about bread once steam from both burners has fogged my kitchen window so thick I can’t tell if it’s snowing. That is my cue.

Mrs. Castellano from across the hall always knocked around then with a foil pan, mostly to see who was over. One year she watched me pull a batch from the basket and said, “Sandwich bread? Somebody raised you better than that.” Then she ate two standing up.

She was right about the bread and wrong about everything else. Soft butter, roasted garlic, parsley, salt and pepper on sandwich bread, five minutes in the basket: that is the garlic toast recipe on the site.

Left on the table, it goes limp in ten minutes. So I wait until the antipasto is cleared, then run it four slices at a time until people stop reaching.

#25 Air Fryer Frozen Sweet Potato Fries

Air Fryer Frozen Sweet Potato Fries

The first bite is the whole point: crisp outside, soft in the middle. Let them sit ten minutes among the platters and elbows and that bite is gone, so they never sit.

Ours go to the card table by the radiator, where I sat for years. A friend from work brought a bag down the first Christmas she came along, and now Mrs. Carbone and the neighbors at that end ask for these before the lasagna.

I make them last, around four, between the pasta and the roast, when the basement basket is free. Frozen fries, olive oil spray, salt and black pepper, a preheated basket at 375. The frozen sweet potato fries recipe on the site is exactly that easy, and they go straight from the basket to the plates.

No peeling, and the oven upstairs never has to make room. The roast keeps it all to itself.

Conclusion

Run the day backward from dinner. Potatoes go in first because they hold, and a tray of them under a clean towel is still good an hour later. Roasted garlic gets done the night before in my own kitchen and rides over in a jar of its own oil. Green things go last, the sprouts and the zucchini and the broccoli, because they don’t hold and nobody wants them limp.

Upstairs, the oven is for the lasagna and nothing else. That rule is older than I am, and the air fryer earned its spot on Nonna’s basement counter by respecting it.

Buon appetito,
Madeline

Similar Posts

WANT TO SAVE THIS ARTICLE?

Enter your email below & we'll send it straight to your inbox.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.